they played each other in 2004
The New York Giants played against the Indianapolis Colts on September 10, 2006 and the Colts won. So, Peyton did beat Eli.
Until one of the two brothers switches teams, they can only play in the Super Bowl, since Peyton plays for an AFC team (Colts) and Eli plays for an NFC team (Giants). Since they have never played against each other in the Super Bowl, they have never played in against each other in the playoffs.
They have played each other 11 times to date.
yes
They have played each other about 50-60 times :) :) :)
They have played each other 34 times and it is called football not 'soccer' thank you.
The very first game of the 2006 regular season was between the Indianapolis Colts and the New York Giants. Both Peyton and Eli started. The Colts won. In the rematch played on September 19, 2010, the Colts won again.
never
a lot
Through the 2012 season, the New York Giants and Minnesota Vikings have played each other 25 times. This includes the playoffs.
They have played nine times with the Raiders winning the majority with 6.