Who is a better quarterback Tom Brady or Kurt Warner?

Answer 1

The fact is that Peyton Manning is the greatest of all time.When you look at his records and see that there isn't 1 QB that threw more tds,more yds or had more wins quicker then manning did.I know that brady fans will say that brady broke manning season single td record by 1 td and they are right.The other side of the story is that brady played all 16 games and played ever quarter that year.Manning on the other hand missed over 4 games that year when you go back and look at how many Quarters they took manning out of because they blew out the other team and didn't want to take a chance of manning getting hurt.

I think that brady should be considered 1 of the greatest but he's not the greatest of all time and the record proves it.I'm tired of hearing annoucers and fans of a QB say that they are the greatest because they have more SB rings.The fact is that football is the ultimate team sport.Fox exsample if it wasn't for Adam Vinatieri the pats would have never won any SBs.His kick won the AFC championship the 1st time they went to the Sb.His kick also won 2 of their sbs in the last minutes.On top of that New England always had a good defence, unlike Manning with the colts.

If it's true what they are claiming then TRENT FIFFER ,KEN STABLER,JIM PLUNKETT, MARK RYPIEN, DOUG WILLIAMS,and JOE THEISMAN are all better then DAN MARINO,JIM KELLY,and FRAN TARKENTON because they all have 1 sb ring and they don't.It's just stupid to claim that a qb is better because he have more sb rings.Hell they have a qb that have 3 sb rings but never played in a sb so i guess he's better then marino to because marino doesn't have any

I live in Louisiana and a huge saints fan.I'm also a big 49ers fan.I remembered JOE MONTANA 1st year.I thought he was the greatest of all time until manning.The fact is that records don't lie.People should give credit where credit is due.

Answer 2

Kurt Warner, because he had more experience and had played in the NFL more years than Brady. Although Brady beat him in a Super Bowl, Kurt Warner is still better.