Kurt Warner
Roethlisberger was the 11th overall pick in the 2004 NFL draft and 1st pick of the Pittsburgh Steelers.
Eli Manning was the first pick of the first round in the 2004 NFL Draft. He was drafted by the San Diego Chargers and was traded that day to the New York Giants for quarterback Philip Rivers.
Norm Snead has: Played himself in "Toast of the Town" in 1948. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "The NFL on CBS" in 1956. Played Himself - Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback in "The NFL on CBS" in 1956. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Philadelphia Eagles Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Minnesota Vikings Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - San Francisco 49ers Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played himself in "This Is Your Life: 30th Anniversary Special" in 1981.
NFL player Phillip Rivers is currently playing for the San Diego Chargers as a star quarterback. He has had many highlights since joining the team in 2004 from the draft. He has been to 4 pro bowls and was quarterback of the year in 2010.
Kerry Collins has: Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Carolina Panthers Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Tennessee Titans Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Carolina Panthers Quarterback in "NFL on FOX" in 1994. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "NFL on FOX" in 1994. Played Himself - 5th Overall Pick in "1995 NFL Draft" in 1995. Played himself in "Jerry Maguire" in 1996. Played Himself - Carolina Panthers Quarterback in "1996 NFC Championship Game" in 1997. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "Super Bowl XXXV" in 2001. Played himself in "Gift of New York" in 2006. Played himself in "2009 CMT Music Awards" in 2009.
phillip rivers
NFL Quarterback Club was created in 1994.
Peyton Manning is the guy you're thinking of. Eli Manning is his brother (QB for the New York Giants). Eli and the Giants won the Super Bowl last year. Even though he is younger than Peyton.
National Football League Quarterback Challenge ended in 2007.
Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger was the 11th overall pick in the 2004 NFL draft.
Jeff Rutledge has: Played Himself - Washington Redskins Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "NFL Monday Night Football" in 1970. Played Himself - Alabama crimson Tide Quarterback in "1978 Sugar Bowl" in 1978. Played Himself - New York Giants Quarterback in "Super Bowl XXI" in 1987. Played Himself - Washington Redskins Quarterback in "Super Bowl XXVI" in 1992. Played Himself - Washington Redskins Quarterback in "1991 NFC Championship Game" in 1992.
It may be Sid Luckman. He is on the list of Jewsih pro football players and he played Quarterback for the Chicago Bears from 1939 to 1950. So, I think this is a good bet.Benny Friedman was the first Jewish Quarterback to play in the NFL, he played for the Giants in early 1930's and he is in the NFL Hall of Fame