Who is better Eli Manning or Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

Peyton is way better, but when you think about it Peyton is just as equally good at Football as Eli is. (But i vote for Eli because that's my opinion, and it only matters on who you like better.)

Answer 2

Eli Manning is not like Peyton Manning by his stats and his passing.Also Peyon has a better rating than eli. Peyton 95 Eli 80.2

Answer 3

Peyton seems better but Eli is much better Peyton. in all are better than the giants but Eli is an underanked player and his stats are 2 times better than his brother

Answer 4

Peyton. Better arm and recievers. The down side to this is Dallas Clark is hurt and out for the season.