What Super Bowl had the most Heisman Trophy winners playing in it?

Answer 1

Through Super Bowl XLIII, there has not been more than two Heisman winners on Super Bowl rosters for any game.

1) Super Bowl I - Paul Hornung of the Packers (1956, Notre Dame) and Mike Garrett of the Chiefs (1965, USC). Hornung did not play in Super Bowl I.

2) Super Bowl XII - Roger Staubach of the Cowboys (1963, Navy) and Tony Dorsett of the Cowboys (1976, Pittsburgh).

3) Super Bowl XIII - Roger Staubach of the Cowboys (1963, Navy) and Tony Dorsett of the Cowboys (1976, Pittsburgh).

4) Super Bowl XVIII - Jim Plunkett of the Raiders (1970, Stanford) and Marcus Allen of the Raiders (1981, USC).

Other Super Bowls that had Heisman winners on rosters:

1) Super Bowl II - Billy Cannon of the Raiders (1959, LSU).

2) Super Bowl IV - Mike Garrett

3) Super Bowl V - Roger Staubach

4) Super Bowl VI - Roger Staubach

5) Super Bowl X - Roger Staubach

6) Super Bowl XIII - Roger Staubach

7) Super Bowl XV - Jim Plunkett

8) Super Bowl XXII - George Rogers of the Redskins (1980, South Carolina).

9) Super Bowl XXXI - Desmond Howard of the Packers (1991, Michigan).

10) Super Bowl XXXIV - Eddie George of the Titans (1995, Ohio State).

11) Super Bowl XXXV - Ron Dayne of the Giants (1999, Wisconsin).

12) Super Bowl XXXVII - Charles Woodson of the Raiders (1997, Michigan).

Answer 2

5