Starting Quarterbacks
No quarterback ever started for two different Super Bowl winners, BUT Craig Morton was the first quarterback in NFL history to start the Super Bowl for two different teams (Dallas in 1971 and Denver in 1978).
Kurt Warner, QB- Arizona was only the second quarterback to start the Super Bowl for two different teams when he played in Super Bowl XLIII on February 1,2009. He was previously the MVP of Super Bowl XXXIV on January 30, 2000, with the St. Louis Rams.
Back-Up Quarterbacks
These two quarterbacks played for two different winning teams in the Super Bowl:
Earl Morrall, QB - Baltimore (III, V), Miami (VII, VIII)
Jeff Rutledge, QB - New York Giants (XXI), Washington (XXVI)
Also the following were on the roster but did not play in one or both of the games.
Matt Cavanaugh, QB - San Francisco (XIX), New York Giants (XXV) - neither
Jim McMahon, QB - Chicago (XX), Green Bay (XXXI) - played in XX
(Boldface Super Bowl numbers are for the winning teams in those games.)
(see related question)
Three quarterbacks have won the Superbowl in their second season in the NFL. The quarterbacks are:
There are four quarterbacks who have won the Super Bowl in their 2nd year in the NFL. They are:
Tom Brady, New England Patriots, drafted 2000, won 2001 season, Super Bowl XXXVI
Kurt Warner, St Louis Rams, undrafted, rookie season 1998, won 1999 season, Super Bowl XXXIV
Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers, drafted 2004, won 2005 season, Super Bowl XL
Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks, drafted 2012, won 2013 season, Super Bowl XLVIII
Peyton Manning. Super Bowl XLI with the Indianapolis Colts and Super Bowl L with the Denvor Broncos.
3
Peyton Manning lost Super Bowl XLIV, and at Tennessee, ranked #3 at the end of the year, lost the 97 Sugar Bowl to Nebraska who were co-national champions with Michigan.
There are four quarterbacks who have won the Super Bowl in their 2nd year in the NFL. They are: Tom Brady, New England Patriots, drafted 2000, won 2001 season, Super Bowl XXXVI Kurt Warner, St Louis Rams, undrafted, rookie season 1998, won 1999 season, Super Bowl XXXIV Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers, drafted 2004, won 2005 season, Super Bowl XL Russell Wilson, Seattle Seahawks, drafted 2012, won 2013 season, Super Bowl XLVIII
Through Super Bowl XLIV, 3. 1) Roger Staubach, Dallas Cowboys - won Super Bowl XII over the Broncos and lost Super Bowl XIII to the Steelers. 2) Joe Theismann, Washington Redskins - won Super Bowl XVII over the Dolphins and lost Super Bowl XVIII to the Raiders. 3) Brett Favre, Green Bay Packers - won Super Bowl XXXI over the Patriots and lost Super Bowl XXXII to the Broncos.
Russel Wilson and Brett Farve are just two of the 6 to 7.
Super Bowl V (Loss) - Craig Morton Super Bowl VI (Win) - Roger Staubach Super Bowl X (Loss) - Roger Staubach Super Bowl XII (Win) - Roger Staubach (Craig Morton, Cowboy starter in SB V, was the opposing QB) Super Bowl XIII (Loss) - Roger Staubach Super Bowl XXVII (Win) - Troy Aikman Super Bowl XXVIII (Win) - Troy Aikman Super Bowl XXX (Win) - Troy Aikman
The steelers 2009-10
Super Bowl V was played in the year 1971.
Super Bowl XLV (45)
Dan Marino was the Quarterback of the Miami Dolphins team that reached Super Bowl XIX after the 1984 season. The Dolphins lost 38-16 to the San Francisco 49ers. Marino is perhaps one of the best NFL quarterbacks that never won a Super Bowl.
103,667 at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California (Super Bowl XVII).
8