Yes, Alan scored five against Sheffield Wednesday on the 19th of September, 1999 during the 1999-2000 English Premier League season.
Only two other players have scored five in a match:Andy Cole (Manchester United) vs Ipswich Town 4/3/1995and Jermain Defoe (Tottenham Hotspur) vs Wigan Athletic22/11/2009.
Shearer
Alan shearer
Efan Ekoku
Yes
The last player to score a total of four goals , and even then his team failed to win , is Andrei Arshavin, from Arsenal who scored four goals in the match with Liverpool. But Liverpool also scored four goals ,2 by Torres and 2 by Benayoun.
arshavin
three
313
15 goals and 15 assists
fabregas fabregas
Tottenham hotspur
30