Thurman Thomas scored 1 touchdown in each of 4 consecutive Super Bowls with the Buffalo Bills.
The Bills are the only team to ever play in 4 consecutive Super Bowls, but lost all four games: Super Bowl XXV, XXVI, XXVII, and XXVIII.
As of Super Bowl LI, the total leaders would be Jerry Rice who scored 8 TDs in his 4 Super Bowl appearances (3 with the 49ers and 1 with the Raiders).
By game, it is a 5-way tie with 3 TDs (James White holds the individual record with 20 points).
Scorers
Roger Craig (49ers) had 3 ( Super Bowl XIX)
Jerry Rice (49ers) caught 3 twice (Super Bowl XXIV and XXIX)
Ricky Watters (49ers) had 3 (Super Bowl XXIX)
Terrell Davis (Broncos) had 3 (Super Bowl XXXII)
James White (Patriots) had 3 and a 2-pt conversion (Super Bowl LI)
The record for both teams is 10 touchdowns as the San Francisco 49ers (7) beat the San Diego Chargers (3) by the score of 49-26 in Super Bowl XXIV. The 75 points scored is the highest of any Super Bowl.
* The 49ers scored 8 touchdowns vs the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XXIX (won 55-10 with one missed extra point). This is the current record for one team.
Most Touchdowns, Career (8)
8 - Jerry Rice, San Francisco, 4 games (8-p)
5 - Emmitt Smith, Dallas, 3 games (5-r)
4 - Franco Harris, Pittsburgh, 4 games (4-r)
4 - Roger Craig, San Francisco, 3 games (2-r, 2-p)
4 - Thurman Thomas, Buffalo, 4 games (4-r)
4 - John Elway, Denver, 5 games (4-r)
Most Touchdowns, Game (3)
3 - Roger Craig, San Francisco vs. Miami, XIX (1-r, 2-p)
3 - Jerry Rice, San Francisco. vs. Denver, XXIV (3-p); vs. San Diego, XXIX (3-p)
3 - Ricky Watters, San Francisco vs. San Diego, XXIX (1-r, 2-p)
3 - Terrell Davis, Denver vs. Green Bay, XXXII (3-r)
3 - James White, New England vs, Atlanta (3-p)
Most Touchdowns, Career (8)
8 - Jerry Rice, San Francisco, 4 games (8-p)
5 - Emmitt Smith, Dallas, 3 games (5-r)
4 - Franco Harris, Pittsburgh, 4 games (4-r)
4 - Roger Craig, San Francisco, 3 games (2-r, 2-p)
4 - Thurman Thomas, Buffalo, 4 games (4-r)
4 - John Elway, Denver, 5 games (4-r)
Most Touchdowns, Game (3)
3 - Roger Craig, San Francisco vs. Miami, XIX (1-r, 2-p)
3 - Jerry Rice, San Francisco. vs. Denver, XXIV (3-p); vs. San Diego, XXIX (3-p)
3 - Ricky Watters, San Francisco vs. San Diego, XXIX (1-r, 2-p)
3 - Terrell Davis, Denver vs. Green Bay, XXXII (3-r)
2 - Max McGee, Green Bay vs. Kansas City, I (2-p)
2 - Elijah Pitts, Green Bay vs. Kansas City, I (2-r)
2 - Bill Miller, Oakland vs. Green Bay, II (2-p)
2 - Larry Csonka, Miami vs. Minnesota, VIII (2-r)
2 - Pete Banaszak, Oakland vs. Minnesota, XI (2-r)
2 - John Stallworth, Pittsburgh vs. Dallas, XIII (2-p)
2 - Franco Harris, Pittsburgh vs. Los Angeles, XIV (2-r)
2 - Cliff Branch, Oakland vs. Philadelphia, XV (2-p)
2 - Dan Ross, Cincinnati vs. San Francisco, XVI (2-p)
2 - Marcus Allen, L.A. Raiders vs. Washington, XVIII (2-r)
2 - Jim McMahon, Chicago vs. New England, XX (2-r)
2 - Ricky Sanders, Washington vs. Denver, XXII (2-p)
2 - Timmy Smith, Washington vs. Denver, XXII (2-r)
2 - Tom Rathman, San Francisco vs. Denver, XXIV (2-r)
2 - Gerald Riggs, Washington vs. Buffalo, XXVI (2-r)
2 - Michael Irvin, Dallas vs. Buffalo, XXVII (2-p)
2 - Emmitt Smith, Dallas vs. Buffalo, XXVIII (2-r)
2 - Emmitt Smith, Dallas vs. Pittsburgh, XXX (2-r)
2 - Antonio Freeman, Green Bay vs. Denver, XXXII (2-p)
2 - Howard Griffith, Denver vs. Atlanta, XXXIII (2-r)
2 - Eddie George, Tennessee vs. St. Louis, XXXIV (2-r)
2 - Keenan McCardell, Tampa Bay vs. Oakland, XXXVII (2-r)
2 - Dwight Smith, Tampa Bay vs. Oakland, XXXVII (2-ret)
Emmitt Smith, Dallas, 3 games , with 5 touchdowns
Emmitt Smith of the Dallas Cowboys with 5.
The New England Patriots
Bo Jackson
Andre Reed
Steve Young with six passing TDs in a single Super Bowl.
The person with the second most touchdowns in Super Bowl history is Dallas Cowboys running back Emmit Smith, who had 5 touchdowns in three Super Bowl games. He is second behind San Francisco 49er wide receiver Jerry Rice, who has 8 touch downs in 4 games in his career.
Emmitt Smith, or Jerome Bettis?
The team with the most was the San Francisco 49ers with 8 touchdowns vs the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XXIX (won 55-10 with one missed extra point). The record for both teams is 10 touchdowns as the 49ers (7) beat the San Diego Chargers (3) by the score of 49-26 in Super Bowl XXIV. The 75 points scored is the highest of any Super Bowl.
6 by Steve Young of the San Francisco 49ers in Super Bowl XXIX against the San Diego Chargers.
49'ers quarterback Joe Montana
The record for both teams is 10 touchdowns as the San Francisco 49ers (7) beat the San Diego Chargers (3) by the score of 49-26 in Super Bowl XXIV. The 75 points scored is the highest of any Super Bowl. * The 49ers scored 8 touchdowns vs the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl XXIX (won 55-10 with one missed extra point). This is the current record for one team, and a record 6 TDs for QB Steve Young.