not 100% sure but id say MAYBE john elway?
Last was Elway
Rob Lytle was the first player from the university of Michigan to score a touchdown in a Super Bowl. He attended the university from 1973 until 1976.
Aaron hernandez
Dion sanders
Herb Adderley of the Green Bay Packers was the first NFL player to return an interception for a touchdown in Super Bowl play. He intercepted a Daryle LaMonica pass and returned it 60 yards for a touch down in Super Bowl II.
Matt Snell went 4 yards around the left end to score the Jets' only touchdown in Super Bowl 3
The first touchdown thrown in Super Bowl 44 was thrown by Peyton Manning to Pierre Garcon in the first quarter.
devin Hester (Chicago) vs Indy
Indianapolis Colts - Peyton Manning Pass to Pierre Garcon
Who_caught_the_first_touchdown_in_superbowl_2009
ravens
Herb Adderley of the Green Bay Packers was the first NFL player to return an interception for a touchdown in Super Bowl play. He intercepted a Daryle LaMonica pass and returned it 60 yards for a touch down in Super Bowl II. There wasn't another interception returned for a touch down until Super Bowl XI.