"Dandy" Don Meredith wore #17 and is a 3x Pro Bowl Quarterback for the Dallas Cowboys. He was a Pro-bowler in 1966, 1967 & 1968.
Eli Manning and Fran Tarkenton.
Paul Hornung of the Green Bay Packers wore number 5 in the first super bowl in 1967. I don't think he played in either game but Pittsburgh's backup quarterback for Super Bowls IX and X, Terry Hanratty, wore number 5.
WR Kevin Williams. Williams wore #85 for the Cowboys between 1993-1996. In Super Bowl XXX, he caught 2 passes for 29 yards and had 1 rushing attempt for 2 yards.
Doug Williams
Fullback Robert Newhouse wore the number in Super Bowls VI and XII.
Though many have worn number 24 for the Dallas Cowboys, only three significant players stand out -- All-Pro and Pro Bowl cornerback Everson Walls (1981-89), cornerback and Super Bowl XXX MVP Larry Brown (1991-95 -- Brown wore number 34 during his brief return to the Cowboys in 1998) and Pro Bowl running back Marion Barber III (2005-10).
Punter Mike Saxon wore No. 4 for the Dallas Cowboys from 1985 to 1992. Placekicker Shaun Suisham wore the number during his first tour of duty with the Cowboys in 2005 and 2006.
Robert Lee
Here is a list of Cowboys players who have worn No. 11 since 1960: 1. Don Heinrich, quarterback (1960). 2. Buddy Humphrey, quarterback (1961). 3. Sonny Gibbs, quarterback (1963). 4. Danny Villanueva, punter/placekicker (1965-67). 5. Bob Belden, quarterback (1969-70). 6. Danny White, quarterback, punter (1976-88). 7. Wade Wilson, quarterback (1995-97). 8. Mike Quinn, quarterback (1998-99). 9. Drew Bledsoe, quarterback (2005-2006). 10. Roy E. Williams, wide receiver (2008-2010). 11. Akwasi Owusu-Ansah, safety (2010). 12. Cole Beasley, wide receiver (2012-present).
Hall of Famer Dan Marino wore the 13 jersey for the Miami Dolphins. Marino can arguable be the best quarterback to play the game without a Super Bowl victory.
DB Mike Gaechter wore #27 for the Cowboys between 1962-1969.
Quarterback Daryle Lamonica wore the number for the Raiders from 1967 to 1974.