Yes
The Indianapolis Colts won three games and lost thirteen games during Peyton Manning's first season (1998).
Colts... Peyton Manning was the MVP
Peyton. Peyton Manning won with the Colts in Super Bowl XLI and Eli Manning won with the Giants a year later in Super Bowl XLII.
InIndianapolis Colts & Miami Dolphins. Colts won 29-17. Naming Peyton Manning MVP
Peyton Manning has played in four AFC Championship games.He won three (2006, 2009, 20013 seasons) and lost one (2003 season).
Peyton Manning and the Idianapolis Colts were 13-3 only to lose the the San Diego Chargers in the Divisonal Playoff 24-28.
The very first game of the 2006 regular season was between the Indianapolis Colts and the New York Giants. Both Peyton and Eli started. The Colts won. In the rematch played on September 19, 2010, the Colts won again.
These two teams have not played in the Championship game since 1958.
Peyton manning won
Peyton Manning
The New York Giants played against the Indianapolis Colts on September 10, 2006 and the Colts won. So, Peyton did beat Eli.
Drew Brees (New Orlean Saints) and Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts) The Saints won