This question's a matter of opinion, however these are the statistics if you want to compare the pair based on numbers:
Mahendra Singh (MS) Dhoni
Test Cricket: 3242 Runs at an average of 37.69, 4 Centuries, 23 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 148. 176 Catches, 26 Stumpings.
ODI Cricket: 6497 Runs at an average of 51.15, 7 Centuries, 43 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 183*. 187 Catches and 61 Stumpings.
Twenty20 Cricket: 480 Runs at an average of 25.26, 0 Centuries, 0 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 46. 11 Catches and 4 Stumpings.
Brendon McCullum
Test Cricket: 3414 Runs at an average of 36.70, 6 Centuries, 19 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 225. 167 Catches and 11 Stumpings.
ODI Cricket: 4181 Runs at an average of 29.44, 3 Centuries, 20 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 166. 222 Catches and 14 Stumpings.
Twenty20 Cricket: 1245 Runs at an average of 36.61, 1 Century, 8 Half Centuries, Highest Score of 116*. 29 Catches and 5 Stumpings.
For a more comprehensive ananysis of the two, see the related links section on their player profiles.
Chat with our AI personalities