Right now Manning is better statistically but Tom Brady and Peyton Manning are probably the two best quarterbacks in the game currently
Tom brady
peyton manning does referee ads now tom brady for the win!
Payton
that is so easy TOM BRADY
It's a team game, it does not revolve around one guy. And besides, both Mannings defeated Brady in the playoffs once.
Which manning? If Eli, I would love to say no, but yes. If Peyton, it's probably a tie, but it all depends on how you look at it. GO GIANTS!! ------------------------ Look at it this way, Peyton Manning indeed has the perfect offense yet a horrifyingly terrible defense. Brady had a great offense & a shutdown defense. Of course, Brady has been to & won more super-bowls. However, the one year Brady had an offense just like Manning's 04 offense, he got a 117.2 QB Rating. Just shy of Manning's 121.1 QB Rating. I believe that Manning is forehead up better than Brady.
right now it is manning but Brett Farve has the most records because he has been around longer
Right now Matt Shuab and Drew Brees are arguably better.
Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning has 6 NFL individual records and Tom Brady has 2
tom brady is way better he has 3 super bowls and I DON'T WANT TO HERE ELI MANNING HAS BEATEN TWICE IN THE SUPER BOWL OK!And another thing eli manning has had 1 good year Tom Brady has had a great year since he was a rookie.eli manning has never had a M.V.P.also it took eli manning 8 years to have a good year not even a great year a good year.
This is merely a opinion based queston and can be argued either way