If the softball was measured in time then check you stop watch. The ball speed at a softball pitching distance would be traveling several hundred miles per hour at time stated. A very fast softball pitcher will have a release to catcher time around .5 seconds.
A baseball pros fastball is on average 92 mph
55-65
75-80 mph
43
The average fastball speed is 92 miles per hour. In 2003, Billy Wagner threw 25 pitches that were 100 miles per hour or faster.
In travel team tournament play, about 55 miles per hour.
About 45 mph
If you've had your mechanics checked and is consistent with your pitches conditioning is next for you. Having a conditioning program will surely increase your speed. A program focusing on core, leg strength will help.
Throw it harder
Bob Gibson has the 7th fastest fastball in major league baseball history. His fastest fastball was clocked at 96 miles per hour.
50- 65mph if thrown hard