MLB player Chase Anderson throws right.
MLB player Chase Anderson bats right.
MLB player Brett Anderson throws left.
MLB player Chase Utley throws right.
MLB player Chase Whitley throws right.
MLB player Chase Utley bats left.
MLB player Chase Headley can bat right or left (i.e. he is a switch hitter).
NHL player Craig Anderson shoots left.
MLB player Chase Whitley bats right.
Left.
This riddle refers to a boomerang. When you throw a boomerang to the right, it travels in an arc and returns to your left side, allowing you to see it again. However, if you throw it to the left, it continues on its path and does not return, so you won't see it again.
For right handed people they do catch with their left and throw with their right. For left handed people, they catch with their right and throw with their left. Both players have to potential to bat from either side of the plate.
Goat Anderson bats left and throws right.