Peyton Manning who played for the Indianapolis Colts from 1998-2011 is the best player to have ever been on the Colts team. Manning was a quarterback and led the team to ten straight playoffs.
Chat with our AI personalities
Joseph Addai -29
Ervin Baldwin -94
Hank Baskett -81
Antoine Bethea -41
Gary Brackett -58
Raheem Brock -79
Donald Brown -31
Melvin Bullitt -33
Gerald Cadogan -?
John Chick -?
Dallas Clark -44
Colin Cloherty -46
Austin Collie -17
Keyunta Dawson -96
Kyle DeVan -66
Ryan Diem -71
Daniel Federkeil -76
Eric Foster -68
Aaron Francisco -43
Dwight Freeney -93
Pierre Garcon -85
Samuel Gigeure -14
John Gill -69
Cody Glenn -52
Anthony Gonzalez -11
Nick Graham -37
Dudley Guice -?
Tyjuan Hagler -56
Roy Hall -?
Rudolph Hardie -97
Mike Hart -32
Kelvin Hayden -26
Ramon Humber -59
Marlin Jackson -28
Tim Jennings -23
Antonio Johnson -99
Charlie Johnson -34
Freddy Keiaho -54
Mitch King -?
Jacob Lacey -27
Terrail Lambert -?
Ryan Lilja -65
Peyton Manning -18
Robert Mathis -98
John Matthews -?
Pat McAfee -1
Fili Moala -95
Devin Moore -?
Daniel Muir -90
Curtis Painter -7
Jamie Petrowski -80
Mike Pollak -78
Jerraud Powers -25
Brandon Renkart -?
Jamey Richard -61
Gijon Robinson -47
T.J. Rushing -20
Bob Sanders -21
Tom Santi -86
Jeff Saturday -63
Clint Session -55
Jamie Silva -40
Chad Simpson -45
Taj Smith -?
Justin Snow -48
Jim Sorgi -12
Matt Stover -3
Jacob Tamme -84
Jaimie Thomas -?
Michael Toudouze -75
Tony Ugoh -67
Adam Vinatieri -4
Reggie Wayne -87
Philip Wheeler -60
Drew Willy -?
Peyton Manning, but only right now, in terms of his stats. Others on the team have potential.
Peyton Manning. No doubt. But, some close seconds would be: Reggie Wayne WR #87 Dallas Clark TE #44 Joeseph Addai RB #29 Marvin Harrison WR #88
This really cannot be answered. If I had to choose, it would probably be Bob Sanders. He has huge muscles, but this is an opinionated question.
Peyton Manning
Curtis Painter is, without doubt, the best player the indianapolis Colts have ever had!
Joseph addai
He is a NFL player for Colts.
Clint Sessions the linebacker