answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

You're essentially asking an opinion here, and mine is: No. Simms was a very good QB, but he only made two pro bowls, and was overshadowed during his playing time by the true legends of the position like Elway, Marino, and Montana. He even pales by comparison to other contemporaries such as Kelly, Esiason, and Moon. Simms played for a team dominated by defense and the running game. He was a very good player, but it is hard to make the case that he was an all-time great when one cannot say he was better than the 7th best player at his position during his own era. http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/S/SimmPh00.htm

User Avatar

Wiki User

15y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Is Phil simms NFL hall of fame material?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General History

Is Phil Rizzuto in the Hall of Fame?

Phil Rizzuto HOFYes. Phil Rizzuto was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Veteran's Committee in 1994


How many sports Hall of Fames are there?

* Alberta Sports Hall of Fame * American Bowling Congress * Americas Cup Hall of Fame * Australian Football (soccer) Hall of Fame * Australian Football Hall of Fame (Australian rules football) * Baseball Hall of Fame * Basketball Hall of Fame * BC Sports Hall of Fame * Billiard Congress of America Hall of Fame * Boston Red Sox Hall of Fame * Canadian Amateur Wrestling Hall of Fame * Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame * Canadian Curling Hall of Fame * Canadian Football Hall of Fame * Canadian Horse Racing Hall of Fame * Canadian Motorsport Hall of Fame * Canadian Rodeo Hall of Fame * Canadian Sports Hall of Fame * Cincinnati Reds Hall of Fame * College Baseball Hall of Fame * College Football Hall of Fame * Colorado Sports Hall of Fame * English Football Hall of Fame * Georgia Sports Hall of Fame * Green Bay Packers Hall of Fame * Hockey Hall of Fame * International Bowling Museum and Hall of Fame * International Boxing Hall of Fame * International Game Fishing Hall of Fame * International Gymnastics Hall of Fame * International Motorsports Hall of Fame * International Surfing Hall of Fame * International Swimming Hall of Fame * International Tennis Hall of Fame * International Women's Sports Hall of Fame * Japanese Baseball Hall of Fame * Lethbridge Sports Hall of Fame * Motorsports Hall of Fame of America * Mountain Bike Hall of Fame * NASCAR Hall of Fame (to be completed in 2009) * National Distance Running Hall of Fame * National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame * National Lacrosse League Hall of Fame /(Indoor Lacrosse) * National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame (USA Thoroughbred Horse Racing) * National Soccer Hall of Fame * National Softball Hall of Fame * National Sprint Car Hall of Fame * National Surfing/Wrestling "Ironman" Hall of Fame * National Track & Field Hall of Fame * National Wrestling Hall of Fame * North Carolina Sports Hall of Fame * Polo Museum and Hall of Fame * Professional Women Bowlers Hall of Fame * Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame * Pro Football Hall of Fame * ProRodeo Hall of Fame * Raymond Sports Hall of Fame * St. Louis Cardinals Hall of Fame Museum * Scottish Sports Hall of Fame * United States Bicycling Hall of Fame * United States Hockey Hall of Fame * United States National Ski Hall of Fame and Museum * U.S. Figure Skating Hall of Fame * US Lacrosse Hall of Fame * U.S. Olympic Hall of Fame * Virginia Sports Hall of Fame * Volleyball Hall of Fame * WCW Hall of Fame * WWE Hall of Fame * World Figure Skating Hall of Fame * World Golf Hall of Fame * Women's Basketball Hall of Fame


Is Bernie Williams Hall of Fame material as a New York Yankee?

Yes


Do you capitalize football hall of fame in a sentence?

Yes, if you are referring to a particular hall of fame, such as, "We visited the National Football League Hall of Fame." No, when referring to a generic or unspecified hall of fame, such as, "He is in the hall of fame," or "He is in the football hall of fame."


Did ted Radcliffe get into the hall of fame?

he did not get into the hall of fame

Related questions

Is Phil Rizzuto in the Hall of Fame?

Phil Rizzuto HOFYes. Phil Rizzuto was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Veteran's Committee in 1994


Can a music producer be inducted in to the rock and roll hall of fame?

Yes. Several "non-performers" are in in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, including producer Phil Spector.


What Hall of Fame pitcher led the NL in losses in 1977 and 1979?

Phil Niekro


What Toronto Blue Jays are now in the hall of fame?

Ricky Henderson, Paul Molitor, Phil Niekro and Dave Winfield are the only players who have once played for the Toronto Blue Jays who were inducted into the Hall of Fame however none of them were inducted into the Hall of Fame as a Blue Jay.


How many sports Hall of Fames are there?

* Alberta Sports Hall of Fame * American Bowling Congress * Americas Cup Hall of Fame * Australian Football (soccer) Hall of Fame * Australian Football Hall of Fame (Australian rules football) * Baseball Hall of Fame * Basketball Hall of Fame * BC Sports Hall of Fame * Billiard Congress of America Hall of Fame * Boston Red Sox Hall of Fame * Canadian Amateur Wrestling Hall of Fame * Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame * Canadian Curling Hall of Fame * Canadian Football Hall of Fame * Canadian Horse Racing Hall of Fame * Canadian Motorsport Hall of Fame * Canadian Rodeo Hall of Fame * Canadian Sports Hall of Fame * Cincinnati Reds Hall of Fame * College Baseball Hall of Fame * College Football Hall of Fame * Colorado Sports Hall of Fame * English Football Hall of Fame * Georgia Sports Hall of Fame * Green Bay Packers Hall of Fame * Hockey Hall of Fame * International Bowling Museum and Hall of Fame * International Boxing Hall of Fame * International Game Fishing Hall of Fame * International Gymnastics Hall of Fame * International Motorsports Hall of Fame * International Surfing Hall of Fame * International Swimming Hall of Fame * International Tennis Hall of Fame * International Women's Sports Hall of Fame * Japanese Baseball Hall of Fame * Lethbridge Sports Hall of Fame * Motorsports Hall of Fame of America * Mountain Bike Hall of Fame * NASCAR Hall of Fame (to be completed in 2009) * National Distance Running Hall of Fame * National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame * National Lacrosse League Hall of Fame /(Indoor Lacrosse) * National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame (USA Thoroughbred Horse Racing) * National Soccer Hall of Fame * National Softball Hall of Fame * National Sprint Car Hall of Fame * National Surfing/Wrestling "Ironman" Hall of Fame * National Track & Field Hall of Fame * National Wrestling Hall of Fame * North Carolina Sports Hall of Fame * Polo Museum and Hall of Fame * Professional Women Bowlers Hall of Fame * Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame * Pro Football Hall of Fame * ProRodeo Hall of Fame * Raymond Sports Hall of Fame * St. Louis Cardinals Hall of Fame Museum * Scottish Sports Hall of Fame * United States Bicycling Hall of Fame * United States Hockey Hall of Fame * United States National Ski Hall of Fame and Museum * U.S. Figure Skating Hall of Fame * US Lacrosse Hall of Fame * U.S. Olympic Hall of Fame * Virginia Sports Hall of Fame * Volleyball Hall of Fame * WCW Hall of Fame * WWE Hall of Fame * World Figure Skating Hall of Fame * World Golf Hall of Fame * Women's Basketball Hall of Fame


Is Bernie Williams Hall of Fame material as a New York Yankee?

Yes


How many Hall of Famers have coached the Lakers?

The lakers have had 4 hall of fame coaches who are John Kundla, Bill Sharman, Phil Jackson and Pat Riley


Do you capitalize football hall of fame in a sentence?

Yes, if you are referring to a particular hall of fame, such as, "We visited the National Football League Hall of Fame." No, when referring to a generic or unspecified hall of fame, such as, "He is in the hall of fame," or "He is in the football hall of fame."


Is evander holyfield in the hall of fame?

No and yes, he is in the Atlanta Hall of Fame.. But is not in the World boxing Hall Of Fame.


Is vic power in the hall of fame?

According to MLB Hall of Fame, Vic Power is not in the Hall Of Fame.


Who is a Slaughter in the hall of fame?

Slaughter in the hall of fame


Did ted Radcliffe get into the hall of fame?

he did not get into the hall of fame