According to the Baseball Almanac, here are the 16 players in the Hall of Fame who were entered as a Yankee:
1 Earle Combs
2 Bill Dickey
3 Joe DiMaggio
4 Whitey Ford
5 Lou Gehrig
6 Lefty Gomez
7 Waite Hoyt
8 Miller Huggins
9 Reggie Jackson
10 Tony Lazzeri
11 Mickey Mantle
12 Joe McCarthy
13 Phil Rizzuto
14 Red Ruffing
15 Babe Ruth
16 Casey Stengel
There are 20 Players, and 2 managers that were inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. You may consider Larry MacPhail, a one time president of the New York Yankees as the 23rd but he was not inducted into the hall as a Yankee. MacPhil was inducted as a baseball executive, with no affiliation with any one team.
Below is a List of people inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame as New York Yankees:
Frank Baker- 3B 1916-19, 21-22
Yogi Berra- C 1946-63, Manager 1964, 84-85 (inducted as Yankee)
Wade Boggs- 3B 1993-97
Roger Bresnahan- C 1901-02
Frank Chance- 1B and Manager 1913-14
Jack Chesbro- P 1903-09 (inducted as Yankee)
Earle Combs- OF 1924-35 (inducted as Yankee)
Stan Coveleski- P 1928
Joe DiMaggio- OF 1936-42, 46-51 (inducted as Yankee)
Bill Dickey- C 1928-46 (inducted as Yankee)
Whitey Ford- P 1950, 53-67 (inducted as Yankee)
Lou Gehrig- 1B 1923-39 (inducted as Yankee)
Lefty Gomez- P 1930-42 (inducted as Yankee)
Joe Gordon- 2B 1938-43, 46 (inducted as Yankee)
Goose Gossage- P 1978-83, 89 (inducted as Yankee)
Clark Griffith- P 1903-07, Manger 1903-08
Burleigh Grimes- P 1934
Bucky Harris- Manager 1947-48
Rickey Henderson- OF 1985-89
Waite Hoyt- P 1921-30 (inducted as Yankee)
Miller Huggins- Manager 1918-29 (inducted as Yankee)
Catfish Hunter- P 1975-79
Reggie Jackson- OF 1977-81 (inducted as Yankee)
Willie Keeler- OF 1903-09
Tony Lazzeri- 2B 1926-37 (inducted as Yankee)
Mickey Mantle- OF 1951-68 (inducted as Yankee)
Joe McCarthy- Manager 1931-46 (inducted as Yankee)
Joe McGinnity- P 1901-02
John McGraw- IF and Manager 1901-02
Johnny Mize- 1B 1949-53
Phil Niekro- P 1984-85
Herb Pennock- P 1923-33 (inducted as Yankee)
Gaylord Perry- P 1980
Branch Rickey- C 1907
Phil Rizzuto- SS 1941-42, 46-56 (inducted as Yankee)
Wilbert Robinson- C 1901-02, Manager 1902
Red Ruffing- P 1930-42, 45-46 (inducted as Yankee)
Babe Ruth- OF 1920-34 (inducted as Yankee)
Joe Sewell- SS 1931-33
Enos Slaughter- OF 1954-59
Casey Stengel- Manager 1949-60 (inducted as Yankee)
Dazzy Vance- P 1915, 18
Paul Waner- OF 1944-45
Dave Winfield- OF 1981-88, 90
16 Hall of Famers
12 Hall of Famers were Boston Red Sox
Fourteen
5
Mel Hall played in 10 games at designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 1991, starting in none of them. , equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in).
16 Hall of Famers
I say Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, Bernie, A-Rod, C C, Jorge Posada, Paul O'Neill, Tex, Mussina and many more.
12 Hall of Famers were Boston Red Sox
3
48
Fourteen
5
Keith Hernandez, the co-MVP of the 1979 season with the World Series Champion Pittsburgh Pirates. Keith also was the captain and hero the 1986 World Series Champion New York Mets
Mel Hall played in 10 games at designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 1991, starting in none of them. , equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in).
Mel Hall played in 11 games at designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 1992, starting in none of them. , equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in).
Mel Hall played in 34 games at designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 1989, starting in none of them. , equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in).
Mel Hall played in 54 games at designated hitter for the New York Yankees in 1990, starting in none of them. , equivalent to 0 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in).