Sandy Alomar- Mets (2007), Indians (1990-00)
Butch Benton- Mets (1978, 80), Indians (1985)
Rick Cerone- Mets (1991), Indians (1975-76)
Joe Ginsberg- Mets (1962), Indians (1953-54)
Junior Ortiz- Mets (1983-84), Indians (1992-93)
Sammy Taylor- Mets (1962-63), Indians (1963)
Butch Benton debuted on September 14, 1978, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on June 15, 1985, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Wayne Cage debuted on April 22, 1978, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on September 30, 1979, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Jason Tyner debuted on June 5, 2000, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on May 12, 2008, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Jacobs Field.
Harry Chiti. In 1962, Harry Chiti was traded from the Cleveland Indians to the New York Mets for the proverbial 'player to be named later'. In 15 games for the Mets, Chiti batted .195. He was sent back to the Indians two months after the trade as the 'player to be named later'. He didn't play another game in the majors after being returned to the Indians.
1998-2004: Los Angeles Dodgers 2005: Boston Red Sox, Cleveland Indians 2006-2008: Boston Red Sox 2009: New York Mets
Neil Allen debuted on April 15, 1979, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on September 19, 1989, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Benny Ayala debuted on August 27, 1974, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on October 2, 1985, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Jay Bell debuted on September 29, 1986, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on September 28, 2003, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium.
Butch Benton debuted on September 14, 1978, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on June 15, 1985, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Phil Hennigan debuted on September 2, 1969, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on July 7, 1973, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium.
Steve Springer debuted on May 22, 1990, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on August 25, 1992, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium.
Darrell Sutherland debuted on June 28, 1964, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium; he played his final game on April 19, 1968, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
Dick Tidrow debuted on April 18, 1972, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on May 7, 1984, playing for the New York Mets at Shea Stadium.
Wayne Cage debuted on April 22, 1978, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on September 30, 1979, playing for the Cleveland Indians at Cleveland Stadium.
David Wright for the outfielder's, infielders, catchers. Johan Santana is the pitchers' captain for the Mets.
Matt Lawton has: Played Himself - New York Mets Right Fielder in "Sunday Night Baseball" in 1990. Played Himself - Chicago Cubs Left Fielder in "Sunday Night Baseball" in 1990. Played Himself - Cleveland Indians Left Fielder in "Sunday Night Baseball" in 1990. Played Himself - Cleveland Indians Right Fielder in "Sunday Night Baseball" in 1990. Played Himself - Cleveland Indians Pinch Hitter in "Sunday Night Baseball" in 1990. Played Himself - AL Right Fielder: Minnesota Twins in "2000 MLB All-Star Game" in 2000. Played Himself - AL Left Fielder: Cleveland Indians in "2004 MLB All-Star Game" in 2004.
Gene Woodling debuted on September 23, 1943, playing for the Cleveland Indians at League Park II/Cleveland Stadium; he played his final game on September 16, 1962, playing for the New York Mets at Polo Grounds IV.