I could only come up with three ballplayers named Gary that played for the New York Yankees.
Gary Roenicke 1986 number 11
Gary Sheffield, 2004 -2006 number 11
Gary Ward, 1987 -1989 Number 22
(numbers can be verified on Baseball-almanac.com)
There is one website that list MLB players that wore the number 33 (God Bless The internet)
It has Gary Ward listed but also notes: This number was not verified for him, but is given on at least one site
Now for the Conspiracy theorists:
If you Add Up Gary Roenicke 11 + Gary Sheffield 11 = You Get Gary Ward's Number 22
Gary Sheffield 11 + Gary Ward 22 = 33
Hmmm
I will leave the link to the page listing players that wore uniform Number 33 (below)
Gary Sheffield wore the number 11 for the New York Yankees.
First baseman Juan Miranda in 2009.
Click on the link below to see all the players that wore #2 for the Yankees.
In recent years, Gary Sheffield and Doug Mientkiewicz would be two names that is most remembered
In 1996, Wade Boggs wore #12 for the Yankees.
Mel Hall Click on the 'Yankees Numbers' link on this page to see all players that wore #27 for the Yankees.
Click on the 'Yankees Numbers' link on this page to see all players that wore #6 for the New York Yankees.
Gary Puckett and the Union Gap.
Tony Fernandez wore uniform number 6 for the 1995 New York Yankees.
Pitcher Dustin Moseley wore #40 for the 2010 Yankees.
Click on the 'Yankees Numbers' link on this pages to learn who wore #18 and every other number throughout Yankee history.
Mike Stanley number 20Mike Stanley wore uniform number 20 for the New York Yankees from 1992 - 1995, then again in 1997.