What is the value of a game-used broken Willie McCovey bat?

Answer 1

The appraisal of any game-used item is a matter of history, documentation, and knowledge of proper manufacture's specifications. Quite obviously, a broken bat is worth less than a nice clean example, but any gamer representing a slugging Hall of Famer has decent value. Willie Stargell used a wide array of different models from various manufacturers. Highest value would be those dating to the earliest days of his career and made by Hillerich & Bradsby (Louisville Slugger). Pre-1970 bats in excellent condition would be worth $350-600; post-1970, $300-400. Stargell bats relating to special events or seasons may be worth significantly more, and more info is needed to accurately appraise your bat.