What are 1887 Old Judge baseball cards worth ungraded?

Answer 1

If the cards are genuine and unaltered they are worth what a comparable condition graded card is worth. If this were not the case one could buy the card, have it graded, and sell the graded card at a locked in profit. If this situation ever did exist one would think that it has been arbed out of the market. If your question was just about the values of Old Judge cards, a solid VG-EX card with a nice photo is worth a minimum of $300. The elevator goes up from there. Cards of Hall of Famers trade for premiums and the rarer cards in the set also trade for premiums. It is a very complicated set with over 500 different players represented in, on average, five different poses each. If you have specific questions consult an established dealer or auction house.