In 2004 the whole Boston Red Sox team received the Sportsman of the Year Award.
Muhammad Ali won the Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year Award once, in 1974.
Brett Favre did of course!
1985 - Darrell Evans
1971 Lee Trevino Golf PGA Player of the Year
1977 Steve Cauthen Horse racing Eclipse Award for Outstanding Jockey
1985 No Selection
Tom Seaver, New York Mets pitcher.
1970 Bobby Orr Hockey NHL MVP
1964 Ken Venturi Golf U.S. Open Champion