In 1975, Gene Swick of Toledo won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1976, Tommy Kramer of Rice won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1977, Guy Benjamin of Stanford won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1978, Steve Dils of Stanford won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1980, Mark Herrmann of Purdue won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1982, John Elway of Stanford won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1968, Chuck Hixson of SMU won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1969, Mike Phipps of Purdue won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1970, Pat Sullivan of Auburn won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1971, John Reaves of Florida won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1959, Dick Norman of Stanford won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.
In 1962, Don Trull of Baylor won the Sammy Baugh Trophy.