Deacon McGuire debuted on June 21, 1884, playing for the Toledo Blue Stockings at League Park; he played his final game on May 18, 1912, playing for the Detroit Tigers at Navin Field.
Deacon Donahue debuted on September 16, 1943 and played his final game on May 26, 1944.
Deacon McGuire played in 41 games at catcher for the Toledo Blue Stockings in 1884, starting in none of them. He made 224 putouts, had 56 assists, and committed 29 errors, equivalent to .707 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had one double play. He had 66 passed balls, 0 wild pitches, 0 opponent stolen bases, and 0 opponent caught stealings.
Deacon McGuire played in 10 games at catcher for the Philadelphia Quakers in 1888, starting in none of them. He made 49 putouts, had 11 assists, and committed 15 errors, equivalent to 1.5 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had one double play. He had 10 passed balls, 0 wild pitches, 0 opponent stolen bases, and 0 opponent caught stealings.
Deacon Van Buren debuted on April 21, 1904, playing for the at ; he played his final game on May 15, 1904, playing for the Philadelphia Phillies at Baker Bowl.
Bill McGuire debuted on August 2, 1988, playing for the Seattle Mariners at Kingdome; he played his final game on September 22, 1989, playing for the Seattle Mariners at Kingdome.
Deacon Jones debuted on September 23, 1916, playing for the Detroit Tigers at Navin Field; he played his final game on August 30, 1918, playing for the Detroit Tigers at Navin Field.
Deacon White debuted on May 4, 1871, playing for the Cleveland Forest Citys at National Association Grounds; he played his final game on October 4, 1890, playing for the Buffalo Bisons at .
Jim McGuire debuted on September 10, 1901, playing for the Cleveland Blues at League Park I; he played his final game on September 28, 1901, playing for the Cleveland Blues at League Park I.
Mickey McGuire debuted on September 7, 1962, playing for the Baltimore Orioles at Memorial Stadium; he played his final game on October 1, 1967, playing for the Baltimore Orioles at Memorial Stadium.
Deacon Phillippe debuted on April 21, 1899, playing for the Louisville Colonels at Eclipse Park II; he played his final game on August 13, 1911, playing for the Pittsburgh Pirates at Forbes Field.
Deacon Donahue debuted on September 16, 1943, playing for the Philadelphia Blue Jays at Shibe Park; he played his final game on May 26, 1944, playing for the Philadelphia Blue Jays at Shibe Park.
McGuire debuted on June 16, 1894, playing for the Cincinnati Reds at League Park II in Cincinnati; he played his final game on June 16, 1894, playing for the Cincinnati Reds at League Park II in Cincinnati.