There are 9 plus 3 often assumed to have Premier League medals who don't Paul Ince Jérémie Aliadière Ray Parlour Geremi Robert Huth Gary Pallister Bryan Robson Stuart Ripley Clayton Blackmore also Jonathan Greening and Gary Walsh were playing for Man United when they won titles but didn't make enough appearances and Paul Merson left Arsenal the year before they won their first Premier League.
It coulld be Peter SchMichael.
Joe Cole Kanu Damien Duff
Jermaine Pennant Glen Johnston
Chris Sutton Roy Keane ? Andrei Kanchelskis
Many players have played both sports and had success in them. Xabi Alonso is one of them.
Three players strike me Theirry Henry, David Beckham and Claude Makelele. To add to the above: Deco, Eidur Gudjohnsen, Giovanni Van Bronckhorst, Henrik Larsson (acquired Premier League medal on appeal despite playing only 7 times on loan at Man Utd). Possibly Gerard Pique as well if he got a premier league winners medal at Man Utd in 2008.