He has gone to the Super Bowl twice, but has only won it once.
The Colts have gone to the playoffs ten times under Manning with a 9-9 game record and one Superbowl title.
As of 2009 The Steelers have gone toSuper Bowl 6 times with all winnings. Dallas Cowboys have gone to Super Bowl 8 times 5 out of the 8 winnings
Bill Belichick and Don Shula have gone to the Super Bowl six times each as of the time of this writing.