Phenomenal Smith debuted on August 14, 1884, playing for the Philadelphia Athletics at Jefferson Street Grounds; he played his final game on June 15, 1891, playing for the Philadelphia Phillies at Philadelphia Baseball Grounds.
Phenomenal Smith played in 58 games at pitcher for the Baltimore Orioles in 1887, starting in none of them. He made 9 putouts, had 99 assists, and committed 20 errors, equivalent to .345 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had one double play.
Phenomenal Smith played in 35 games at pitcher for the Baltimore Orioles in 1888, starting in none of them. He made 8 putouts, had 50 assists, and committed 17 errors, equivalent to .486 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had one double play.
Phenomenal Smith played in 5 games at pitcher for the Philadelphia Athletics in 1889, starting in none of them. He made no putouts, had 4 assists, and committed one error, equivalent to .2 errors per game (estimate based on total games played in). He had one double play.
NFL player Will Smith played for Texas Tech.
NBA player Russ Smith played for Louisville.
NFL player Jerome Smith played for Syracuse.
NFL player Steve Smith played for Utah.
NFL player Torrey Smith played for Maryland.
NFL player Lee Smith played for Marshall.
NFL player Jacquies Smith played for Missouri.
NFL player Andre Smith played for Alabama.
NFL player Tyron Smith played for USC.