I think it was Joe Montana
Not through Super Bowl XLVI.
Craig Morton: Super Bowl V, Dallas Cowboys Super Bowl XII, Denver Broncos
Both John Elway and Tom Brady have the most Super Bowl appearances at 5 each. Terry Bradshaw and Troy Aikman have 4 Super Bowl appearances each.
I don't know if this answers your question because he actually won the super bowl more than twice, but Tom Brady of the New England Patriots has won the super bowl twice.
The New York Giants have won four super bowls. The following quarterbacks have won a Super Bowl with the Giants: Super Bowl XXI - Phil Simms Super Bowl XXV - Jeff Hostetler Super Bowl XLII -Eli Manning Super Bowl XLVII - Eli Manning See the related link to read more.
Kurt Warner won Super Bowl XXXIV but lost Super Bowl XXXVI with the St. Louis Rams, then lost Super Bowl XLIIII with the Arizona Cardinals.Craig Morton also was the starting Quarterback to lose the Super Bowl for a NFC team Dallas Cowboys in SB V and an AFC team Denver Broncos SB XII.Kurt Warner Super Bowl appearances :Super Bowl 34 (January 30, 2000) St. Louis Rams 23-16 Tennessee TitansSuper Bowl 36 (February 3, 2002) New England Patriots 20-17 St. Louis RamsSuper Bowl 43 (February 1, 2009) Pittsburgh Steelers 27-23 Arizona Cardinals
Maybe. They have a lot more confidence now, a great coach, great players, and more fan support, but it isn't easy to make it to a Super Bowl Never ever ever will they.
The Super Bowl.